I’ve had the idea for a while now that these last few years have been all about change, and that my task has been to learn how to deal with it, how to make my peace with the many endings and beginnings that seem to be part and parcel of mid-life. It’s been years since we moved away from the neighborhood where Henry and Jack grew up. And although we’ve returned for visits with old friends and neighbors, our roots are elsewhere these days. Our boys, eleven and fourteen when they last spent a night in our old house, are now seventeen and twenty, pretty much full-grown. And our current life in New Hampshire (one son halfway through college, the other finishing high school) bears no resemblance to the one we left behind (two little boys in the backyard, playing catch until dark).
The image I’ve had in my mind–of doors closing for good on the past and new ones opening before us–seemed practical and realistic. Settled now, with a bit of history in our not-so-new house, I’ve come to accept the fact that all children grow up eventually and, in the process, families do change, and sometimes they even move away from cherished places. Life chapters end. Pages turn. We acknowledge endings, create new beginnings, yearning all the while for permanence and security.
And year by year, as my own family has shaped new rituals and memories in a new place, I’ve struggled to make my fragile peace with Thomas Wolfe’s famous truism, “you can’t go home again.” (Well, I keep telling myself, you can’t, not in any literal sense. The day you sign those closing papers, the locks get changed and what was once yours no longer is.)
And yet, lately I’ve experienced one homecoming after another, homecomings at once unexpected, wonderful, and profound. In fact, I am typing these words while sitting on the porch of our former next-door neighbor’s house, gazing across the driveway at our own old green house, solid and quiet and still on this hot summer afternoon. Plunked back into our old neighborhood –and, in some ways, right back into our old life — I can’t help but think about homecomings in a more spiritual sense, homecomings that keep reminding me that everything is connected after all, and that although life is always changing, beginnings and endings might be little more than illusions, constructs of our limited human minds that fail to take into account the bigger mystery.
A few months ago, Jack was invited to participate in a four-days-a-week training program in Boston this summer –long hours, hard work, lots to learn. “If you really want to do this,” I told him at the time, “I’m sure we can figure out a way to make it work.” He gave it some thought, and said yes. And I started looking into summer sublets on Craig’s List and putting out feelers to every friend within fifteen miles of the city. A few promising leads fizzled. And then our former next-door neighbors and best friends from across the driveway offered us their house. They would be in South Africa and could use a house sitter; we were welcome to move in for the month they would be gone.
And so it was that last Sunday night, Jack and I let ourselves in to the house where he spent some of the happiest hours of his childhood playing with his two best buddies, Nick and Will.
“This feels pretty weird,” we said in unison, as we flicked on lights and called the cat’s name. Our friends were halfway across the world by the time we showed up, and neither of us quite knew what to do in their house without them in it, too. I put some food in the fridge, opened the windows, unpacked my bag, and then tossed and turned all night, feeling like a trespasser in my best friend’s bedroom.
Jack, veteran of countless sleep overs here and epic games of hide and seek, knows every nook and cranny of this house, but in the morning he told me that he’d had trouble settling down himself. He was at a bit of a loss, missing his friend and not quite comfortable sprawled out in Nick’s bed instead of in his usual spot, in a sleeping bag on the floor.
As it turns out, our old house is empty this summer as well, the owners having spent the last year abroad. And so it’s been all too easy to imagine that, any minute now, we’ll just saunter across the driveway and be at “home” again. From the outside, everything looks exactly as it did when we lived there. Which means I can fool myself into thinking that, inside, my dishes are stacked in the cupboards as always, our family photos are still on the walls, Steve is working away in his upstairs office, Henry’s picking out tunes on the piano in the living room.
All during our first day here, I had to remind myself: those weeds in the garden are not mine to pull, the blueberries ripening by the garage, not ours to pick, even if no one else is around to harvest them. Jack has felt the tug in a different way. The other night, looking over at our old house as dusk fell, he mused, “If I ever get rich enough to build my own house, I think I’ll make it exactly like this one. And then it would always feel like I was back home again.”
Meanwhile, we are making ourselves at home again, right next door. After a few days in Carol’s kitchen, I know where the pot holders are and how to use her coffee maker. The New York Times is on the front lawn by the time I take Jack to his train at seven. I’ve gone back to my old yoga studio for class each morning, taken long walks with old friends, visited the local farmer’s markets (better than ever), and bought Jack a pizza at Joe’s (exactly the same).
It’s amazing how comfortable we’ve come to feel, how at home we are here in our old world, even after all this time away. It seemed perfectly natural for Jack’s pal Will, who grew up in the house behind ours, to saunter through the front door last night and say “hi.” Within five minutes those two six-foot-tall guys were down on the floor, practicing a wrestling hold, sweaty and laughing, as if they were both eleven again.
Two days ago, I took a stroll through our old backyard and recalled the planting of every bush and perennial and tree. Remembering all the hours of hard work Steve and I put in over the course of our thirteen years here, trying to create our own version of paradise, I allowed myself a weepy moment at the sight of the weed-choked gardens and untended beds, as overgrown and rampant with vines as Sleeping Beauty’s entangled castle. But then, all of a sudden, something in me lightened, and I think I let that particular sadness go for good. It occurred to me that this old, odd house that was our home for so long — built as a barn in 1850, gutted and turned into a house for humans in 1923 — has withstood both love and neglect, family life and family deaths, homecomings and goings, for over a century and a half. A hundred years from now, it will stand there still, holding its own silent counsel. Like all those who came before us, and all those who will come after, we were just a few mortals passing through. No big deal in the grand scheme of things.
And yet, the seeds we sowed during our own brief time here were not just for the vegetables and flowers that brought us so much passing pleasure, but also seeds of love and friendship that continue to bear fruit in our lives today, despite the passage of time and the challenges of distance. The day we moved away six years ago — a day that I saw at the time as a wrenching finale to our sons’ childhoods and the life we’d known — was in fact no such thing. It was just a day. Life transforming itself the way it does: this happens, and then that happens. In Buddhism it is said that all causes and conditions are related; that the world exists in a state of interdependence. Because one thing arises, another arises; because of this, that.
And so it occurs to me now that I was mistaken to ever think of life as a simple series of endings and beginnings. How self-defeating, to try so hard to grab hold of those things I wanted to keep intact, with the idea that permanence just might be possible. Sitting here by myself, looking at the empty shell of a house that was once stuffed full of us — but that is now the center of another family’s universe — I think I finally get it: home really is the place where I am right now, if I choose to make it so. And if I’m awake, and open, and loving what is, then I am always at home, no matter what roof is above my head or what return address I stamp in the upper corner of an envelope.
Addendum: Last week, I wrote about a phone call I received seven years ago from my former sister-in-law, asking me to read her dying friend’s manuscript. Beverly’s husband sent that link on to Jennie — and after reading my post, she picked up the phone and called me again. This time, thanks to the imminent publication of The Sisters from Hardscrabble Bay, we connected right away and heart-to-heart, like the dear friends we were thirty years ago. Jennie works in a book store now, and within minutes we’d hatched a plan — for me to visit in the fall, do a reading at the store, have dinner, and spend the night with her family. It was as if yet another handful of karmic seeds planted in the distant past were suddenly blossoming in this garden of the present moment. Phone pressed to my ear, listening to Jennie’s familiar voice after all this time, hearing such love and kindness in her words — that was quite a homecoming, too.
maryanne says
Your post, as always, Katrina, stirred things in my heart. We are struggling with endings and impermanence particularly at the moment, with the death of my mother 9 days ago, here at home. Her home, too, where she’d lived for 5 years, but also not her home, as necessity meant we nursed her upstairs, near us, rather than in what has been her own space. So lately, since she died, I’ve been spending evenings in" her" rooms, her home, which feels, right now ,more like my home to me than my own part of the house. And home, and feelings of home, and the fragile impermanence of things and people that mean so much to us, are much on my mind and in my heart. No answers, only questions. And hope, I suppose, that in some way it will all be alright in the end.
Lindsey says
As always, I read your words and immediately start crying, with the sense of a familiar spirit. The same questions haunt me, the same sense of loss flits around the corners of every day. How to let go of that frantic grabbing-hold, that desperate need to hang on tight … I hope someday I’ll figure it out. For now I just listen and watch teachers like you and feel I am a tiny bit closer to that goal.
(are you back at the studio on Mass Ave?)
Judy says
I always love your posts, Katrina. I love reading about what you are up to. I can just see you and your son sitting on that front porch, talking about your ‘old’ life there. I love it when my kids are reflective and I can see a glimpse into their souls.. One of the things my oldest son has asked for, for a graduation gift, is a picture of each house he’s lived in. He counted it up and thinks there are 11. I’m not sure that number’s right but am afraid he might be close.
And in all those moves we have discovered something. Although you can never truly ‘go home again’, home is truly where the heart is. In the last few cross country moves we’ve lived in extended stay hotels for months at a time and I saw in our then toddler’s trusting eyes that home is really and truly just the place where all the people you love gather. Big house in Utah or tiny hotel room in New York.
I love our house here in NY. I was just sharing with my mother in law this weekend about how I dread selling it some day. To my husband it is a pile of projects waiting to be done. To me it is this place we tore down and built up and made our own in the past four years. We’ve reconfigured rooms and changed the whole feel of the house, making it, I feel, ‘ours’. I can’t imagine another family coming in to our domain.
But I’m sure when the time is right we will move on. And like your old house, another family will move in and make it their own. Life moves along and homes move along too.
Great post. You always write things that stir something in me. Thanks for that. 🙂
Judy
justonefoot.blogspot.com
Kate Wicker says
Beautiful.
Privilege of Parenting says
"…beginnings and endings might be little more than illusions, constructs of our limited human minds that fail to take into account the bigger mystery"
So lovely to be inter-depending and inter-existing with you, Katrina. Having just completed our garden in time for a gathering of dear friends, I think of the once-loved and neglected state where we started, and of the inevitable time when we will not be harvesting tomatoes from the beds or tumbling the composter.
Yes, home is where we are right now—and even more so, our timeless world of all things seemingly past and future mingle in a oneness that ultimately means that we’re all home together right now.
Thank you for helping us stay present to this all-important mindfulness. Wishing you a summer as present as this post, the taste of fruit and the continued trust in the soft freedom of the moment.
Elissa says
Oh, I love that part about always being home, wherever we are, if we choose to make it so. It’s so easy to forget sometimes, at least for me.
Thank you, Katrina, for this beautiful reminder!
Kristen @ Motherese says
Every morning when I see my boys for the first time I feel as though they’ve grown impossibly big overnight. And I think about how I might invent a device to keep them small and innocent and at home for as long as possible. But your lovely post has reminded me once again that there isn’t necessarily anything wrong with growing up and moving on because it so often seems that we end up coming back – literally or metaphorically – to the very place we’re meant to be. Thank you, Katrina.
Elizabeth@Life in Pencil says
I love the sentiment that "home really is the place where I am right now, if I choose to make it so," a concept I’ve been struggling to embrace and live for years. Personally, I feel less of a tug of the past and more of a pull towards the future. Having just returned from a visit to my hometown, where my dad insisted that we drive past the house I grew up in "for old time’s sake," I didn’t feel much. But for him, driving past the house — now repainted, the playhouse he built for me when I was 7 years-old finally torn down — was clearly heart-breaking. I am always looking for "home" in my future circumstances — "someday I’ll feel settled", I say — but have to remind myself that home can be where I am right now.
I am forwarding your post to my best friend, who has been itching to move out of Las Vegas to a property in rural Utah. Just yesterday she said to me that the timing wasn’t right, and that they were temporarily abandoning their plans to move, focusing instead on making their current home really be their home.